The Pistons Present a Real Problem for the Knicks

I suppose after winning eight in a row, it was inevitable that the Knicks would lay an egg. And last night in Motown they laid a beaut: a 118-80 drubbing at the hands of the Detroit Pistons. The only bright spot was that coach Mike Brown was able to rest his starters in the fourth quarter. Actually, he could've pulled them at half time.

There will be those who will be tempted to dismiss this loss, arguing that with Karl-Anthony Towns, O.G. Anunoby and Deuce McBride out with injuries, the Knicks were shorthanded. The problem with that argument is that all three players were in the rotation a month ago when they got smoked by this very same Pistons team, which I would point out was without their number one center Jalen Duren last night. 

Then there will be those who will point out, perhaps with some validity, that regular season games don't mean all that much. After all, the Knicks went 0-4 against the Boston Celtics during the regular season last year and look what happened in the playoffs. That is certainly true, but I would counter that the Celtics were a flawed team that had become over reliant on the three, and it finally came back to bite them against the Knicks. 

This Pistons team has no discernible flaws. True, they're not the Chicago Bulls of the '90s, or the L.A. Lakers of the '80s; hell, they're not even as talented as the Knicks. But, pound for pound, they are the toughest team in the NBA to play against. They pushed the Knicks to six games in last year's playoffs and they are more than capable of beating them in this year's playoffs. 

What is it about this Pistons team that makes them such a dangerous opponent for the Knicks? In a word, it's their size. They are big and they play big. If they wore skates, they'd be the Philadelphia Flyers of the '70s. They aren't merely content with beating their opponents; they want to send a message: enter the paint at your own peril. It's no secret that they are the most penalized team in the NBA; when they foul you, you know you've been fouled. No slap on the wrist or tug on the jersey. Your ass is on the court. To quote Eddie Murphy from 48 Hours, "Did that hurt? It looked real painful from here."

Much as I applaud Leon Rose for not gutting the team to land Giannis Antetokounmpo, and for acquiring Jose Alvarado at the trade deadline, the failure to add size in the front court could come back to haunt him in the postseason. What good is having another ball handler on the bench when your starters are getting mauled by a more physically dominant opponent? And don't kid yourself; while Cade Cunningham is one of the most talented guards in the league, the majority of his teammates would make the Broad Street Bullies blush with pride.

Barring an early round upset, the prohibitive favorites to advance to the NBA finals will likely have to go through Detroit to get there. And that's a problem because everything the Knicks do well, the Pistons excel at preventing. Beating the Celtics last year came down to making adjustments, especially in the fourth quarter. But how do you adjust for height and weight? 

In the late 1980s, the NBA was forced to endure a reign of terror. A Pistons team led by the likes Bill Laimbeer and Dennis Rodman ran rough shot over their opponents. The infamous fight between Laimbeer and Larry Bird in game three of the '87 Eastern Conference finals remains to this day a stain on the sport. There are parallels between that Pistons team and this one; parallels that the league - and especially the Knicks - would do well to take notice of.

In the 1990s, New York was one of the best teams in the NBA. But their Kryptonite was the Chicago Bulls. No matter how hard they tried, they just couldn't beat them. This Knicks team is also one of the best in the NBA. Will the Pistons end up being their Kryptonite, or will they find a way to beat them and hopefully put an end to a 53 year-old curse?

Don't Do It, Leon

“You're never as good as you think you are when you win; and you're never as bad as you feel when you lose.”

― Joe Paterno

This has certainly been one of the strangest Knicks seasons we've seen in a very long time. A 23-9 start that had fans thinking championship; followed by a 2-9 skid that had them jumping off a bridge; and now a 6-0 streak that has them giddy all over again. There are roller coasters that have less excitement. 

While it remains to be seen whether these last six games are indicative of who they are as a team, there are some very encouraging signs that this latest win streak just might be the real deal. 

For instance, their average margin of victory has been an impressive 23.6 points. True, one of those wins came against the lowly Nets. But even if you subtract that game, the margin is still 17.6 points. To put that in perspective, last season, the Oklahoma City Thunder had an NBA best 12.9 point differential while going 68-14.

Secondly, their defensive effort during this stretch has been simply off the charts. They've allowed an NBA low 91.8 points per game. Conversely, during their 2-9 skid, they allowed 119.8 points per game. A dramatic turnaround. 

And lastly, Karl Anthony Towns has become a new man. The 7-0 center had been struggling this season to find an identity in Mike Brown's system. Over the last three games, he appears to have found it. Check out his slash line below:

@ Tor: 8 points / 22 rebounds / 0 PF / +19 

vs Por: 14 points / 20 rebounds / 1 PF/ +17 

vs LAL: 11 points / 13 rebounds / 3 PF/ +23

That averages out to 11 points / 18.3 rebounds / 1.3 PF / +19.7 per game. It's those last two stats that jump off the page. During his tenure with the Knicks, KAT has been known for getting into early foul trouble and being a sieve on defense. Before these last three games, he was averaging 3.7 personal fouls and a plus 3.58 per game this season. If Towns can keep up this pace, the Knicks will be very difficult to beat in the playoffs.

Which brings me to the number one topic on everyone's mind: Giannis Antetokounmpo. 

I have been adamant that unless Leon Rose can convince the Milwaukee Bucks to accept KAT straight up for Giannis, he should just walk away. Now I'm convinced that even if the Bucks agree to a swap, Rose should still walk away. And for two reasons: One, the Knicks need a shutdown center who can score. Much as I love Mitchell Robinson, there's no guarantee he will be available every game, and even when he is, he's a liability offensively. Secondly, and I cannot stress this enough, Giannis is injury prone. He's had four calf injuries over the last 19 months; two of them non-contact. Imagine trading one or more of your best players at the deadline for a player who gets injured right before the playoffs begin.

And even if Giannis is healthy, I still don't get all the hoopla over him. True, he's a dominant player in the paint, but from the perimeter, he's anything but. Compare and contrast his career stats with Nikola Jokic. 

Antetokounmpo:

Jokic:

There's no comparison. Now if the Denver Nuggets ever call up the Knicks offering to trade Jokic to them, the first words out of Rose's mouth should be, "pick any three players not named Jalen Brunson and I'll send a private jet to pick him up."

But I seriously doubt the Nuggets will be calling anytime soon. Would you? Me neither.

So why would the Bucks be willing to trade Giannis? Teams only trade their stars when they conclude that they can no longer win with them. And if the Bucks no longer believe they can win with Giannis, why would the Knicks believe they can? Why on Earth would they want an injury-prone power forward that, since he last won a championship in 2021, has exactly one playoff series win in the last four seasons?

And then there are the players to consider. Think about the effect Giannis will have on a Knicks locker room that was two wins away from its first finals appearance since 1999. This isn't Mark Messier in '94; not even close.

I’ve been watching the NBA since the ‘70s. I’ve seen the greats like Julius, Walton, Kareem, Magic, Bird, Jordan, Barkley, Duncan, Shaq, Kobe, LeBron, Steph, KD and Joker. With all due respect to Giannis, he doesn't belong in that group. Great players make other players around them better, like LeBron did with the Cleveland Cavaliers and KD almost did with the Nets.

I've seen this movie before: New York team - fill in the blank - trades for an established star to put it over the top. It never ends well.

Here's the bottom line: Rose either believes in this team or he doesn't. If he does, he needs to let it cook. If they fail to make it to the finals, he can always revisit Giannis over the summer, assuming he's still available. 

Sometimes the best trades are the ones you don't make.

This Was the Shortest Window in Rangers History

When Jeff Gorton sent out his letter on February 8, 2018, informing the fanbase that the Rangers were going to be sellers at the trade deadline, it took everyone by surprise. Despite losing seven of their last eight games, the Blueshirts were still in contention for a playoff spot. This was a team that had made the playoffs seven straight years, advanced to two conference finals and one Cup final. Certainly there was a move or two the Rangers GM could've made to make it eight straight years.

But Gorton could see the writing on the wall. Even before the 1-7 skid, there were tell-tale signs that this core had run its course. As difficult as it was to pull the plug, he did what he thought was best for the franchise. We can debate how the rebuild went down, but not why.

Fast forward eight years. Chris Drury, like his predecessor, could also see the writing on the wall. So he sent out his own letter to the fanbase, giving them the bad news. However, this current Rangers team, in no way, shape, or form bears any resemblance to the one Gorton tore down. Two seasons removed from winning the Presidents' trophy, this team is in year two of a steep decline. Not only are they not in contention for a playoff spot, they are currently in last place in the Eastern Conference. The only thing keeping them from last place in the league are the bottom feeders in the Western Conference. 

Going all the way back to when the NHL expanded to twelve teams in 1967, I can't remember a shorter window for this franchise. All the Rangers have to show for a four-year rebuild is two trips to the conference finals and one bitter first-round exit at the hands of the Devils. Three fucking years! If your financial advisor gave you that kind of return on your investments, you'd fire him. Fortunately for Drury, he works for James Dolan, where loyalty is valued over competence.

When the final chapter is written on this team, its legacy will be that it relied way too much on special teams and goaltending to mask the flaws on its roster; flaws that were exposed by better teams like the Tampa Bay Lightning in 2022 and the Florida Panthers in '24. Their sudden rise and fall should serve as a warning to every GM in the league that there are no shortcuts when it comes to building a championship team. You either have the stomach to do it the right way or you botch it, like Drury did.

Not that there weren't some good moments. If Jacob Trouba doesn't take a holding penalty in the second period of game three against the Bolts, the Blueshirts probably would've won that game and taken a 3-0 series lead. Who knows? Maybe they would've advanced to the finals. But as Don Cherry said when the Bruins lost to the Canadiens in the '79 semifinals, "If my aunt had balls she'd be my uncle."

So now what? Carson Soucy was the first to be dealt: to the Islanders for a third-rounder. Next up will be Artemi Panarin. The winger has been a healthy scratch the last two games due to "roster management," which is short for your ass is outta here as soon as we find the right team. After that, who knows? Vincent Trocheck, Alexis Lafreniere, Braden Schneider, all could be gone in the next couple of weeks. The guy I feel sorry for is Vladislav Gavrikov. The 6-3, 220 pound defenseman undoubtedly left money on the table to come here and play with his buddy Panarin. With Panarin gone and the prospect of the Rangers being in rebuild mode for the next few years. I wouldn't be surprised if Vlady ends up asking for a trade; right after he fires his agent. 

As for the rebuild, the biggest problem Drury will have is Dolan. Let's face it, the man handles bad news about as well as a vampire handles a sunrise. He fired John Davidson and Gorton because he grew impatient with the progress of their rebuild. Well, guess what? Rebuilds that take less than five years are not rebuilds; they're retools. Take a good look at the Detroit Red Wings. It took Steve Yzerman seven years to complete his rebuild, and now the Wings are in second place in the Atlantic division. In Anaheim, Pat Verbeek is in year five of his rebuild, and the Ducks currently hold the last wild card spot in the Western Conference, albeit with the help of two Rangers castaways: Trouba and Chris Kreider. 

To paraphrase a well-known song, you can't hurry success. In the cap era, the four most successful teams have been the Pittsburgh Penguins, the Chicago Blackhawks, the Lightning and the Panthers. All four have won multiple Stanley Cups and all four had cores that were built primarily through the draft and later supplemented through trades and a few free-agent signings. The Rangers attempted to do it the other way around, in essence putting the cart before the horse.

The trade for Trouba and the subsequent signing of Panarin in the summer of 2019 - celebrated at the time - in retrospect, short-circuited a rebuild that needed more time. That affected the development of Kaapo Kakko and Lafreniere, both of whom were consigned to bottom six roles on a team that now had unrealistic expectations foisted upon it. The acquisitions of Barclay Goodrow and Ryan Reaves in Drury's first offseason were the direct result of an overreaction to the Tom Wilson incident at the Garden; and that spelled the end of Pavel Buchnevich's career on Broadway; which in turn led to a litany of deadline deals to fill the vacancy on the Mika Zibanejad line. Indeed, virtually every transaction Drury has made during his tenure as GM and President has been reactionary and was done to accelerate a process that in his heart he had to have known would be short-lived, if it worked at all.

And now that reality has caught up with him and the franchise, the sixty-four thousand dollar question is this: Will he and his boss finally admit that they fucked up and do it right this time? Or will they repeat the same mistake? Knowing this organization, it'll probably be the latter. But let's be optimistic for a change. After all, Dolan finally cried uncle with respect to the basketball operation and hired someone who actually knows how to put together a roster the right way. Say what you want about Leon Rose, but over the last four seasons, the Knicks have been one of the best teams in the NBA. Frankly, they haven't looked this good since the 1990s. It's amazing what you can accomplish when you let your employees do their jobs.

So how does Drury excatly "do his job?" By stripping it down to the studs, that's how. I realize that'll be hard with Zibanajad and J.T. Miller holding no-move clauses, but you can still rebuild around them. Trade as many veterans as you can regardless of the fallout; accumulate draft capital; and, above all else, resist the temptation to go on a spending spree this or next summer. In other words, no more Panarins for the foreseeable future.

Next, play the kids, and by play, I mean in the top six, not the bottom six. Play them on the power play; play them on the penalty kill; play them at 4v4; PLAY THEM. It's time to find out whether Gabriel Perrault is the real deal or whether there was a legitimate reason why twenty-two other teams passed on him in the 2023 Draft.

This will be painful, especially if Panarin gets traded to the Islanders and they re-sign him to a five year extension; the Devils aren't going anywhere; and the nightmare of the late '90s and early 2000s is still fresh in the minds of many fans, this one included. Well, at least the Rangers will have solid goaltending during the rebuild, thanks to Drury signing Igor Shesterkin to an eight year, $92 million contract extension last year. Jesus, talk about having a Porsche in your driveway.

You know what they say: no pain, no gain.

Rangers fans have seen more than their fair share of pain; it's the gain that's been missing.

Leon Rose's Next Move Will Be His Most Consequential

With the Rangers in the midst of their second rebuild, retool - or whatever the fuck Chris Drury is calling it - in eight years, the Knicks approach this year's trade deadline with one purpose: to get a team with championship aspirations across the finish line.

This will be Leon Rose's sixth trade deadline since he was hired by James Dolan in March of 2020 to run the franchise, and it will be, by far, his most consequential. With the Eastern Conference wide open, Rose cannot afford to waste this opportunity. But he also can't afford to panic, which is pretty much what every Knicks fan on Twitter has been doing since the NBA Cup. How some of these people are allowed out in public is beyond me.

Let's face it: the roster Rose assembled in the summer of 2024, despite knocking off the Boston Celtics in the second round of last season's playoffs, clearly has flaws. Yes, they've won their last two games, but prior to that, they had lost nine of eleven and looked more like a play-in team than a title contender. The question isn't whether some changes need to be made, but how many and to what extent. 

Mike Brown was hired to transform an offense that had become predictable as dirt under Tom Thibodeau, and for a while there it looked as if he had accomplished the impossible. The starters weren't logging as many minutes as they were the last few seasons; the bench, long an afterthought under Thibs, was making significant contributions. On the surface, everything appeared to be going smoothly. After beating the Pelicans on December 29, New York was 23-9, one game behind the first place Detroit Pistons. To quote Clyde Frazier, the Knicks were "movin' and groovin'."

And then everything began to fall apart. The Knicks blew a late fourth-quarter lead to the Spurs in San Antonio; they were then routed by the Sixers at home and the Pistons in Detroit; they even lost to the lowly Kings in Sacramento. They now sit in fourth place in the Eastern Conference, a half game ahead of the Cleveland Cavaliers.

While there are many issues besetting this team, the most egregious appears to be Karl-Anthony Towns. After an impressive maiden season on Broadway, the 7-0 center has had a rough time adjusting to Brown's system. He is averaging only 20.5 points per game, down four from the previous season. Worse, he has looked disjointed at times and even sullen. In his last game against the Sixers in Philly, KAT fouled out after a season-low 16 minutes, scoring a measly 10 points and grabbing six rebounds. Had it not been for Mitchell Robinson, the Knicks might very well have lost that game.

Towns has been the ultimate enigma. On the one hand, there's no denying his talent; on the other, no player on this team is more frustrating to watch. Fouls have plagued him throughout his NBA career. It is inexplicable that after eleven seasons he still doesn't know how to set a screen. Adding insult to injury, Towns has the audacity to complain when he gets called for the foul, as if the ref was Mr. Magoo. If it weren't so sad, it would be hysterical.

Almost as frustrating as his foul troubles is his inconsistent offensive production. When facing teams with big front courts, he tends to struggle. It's no coincidence that two of his worst offensive performances this season came against the Sixers and the Pistons; two teams that the Knicks could well face in the postseason.

The problem for the Knicks is that when KAT isn't scoring, he's pretty much useless on the court. The man can't defend to save his life; indeed, the one thing Brown and Thibs both have in common is that they would often substitute Towns for Robinson late in the game with a lead.

By no means is Towns the only culprit when it comes to defense. Jalen Brunson isn't exactly Gary Payton. But unlike KAT, Brunson doesn't wilt in big moments. If anything, the tougher the opponent, the more he seems to rise to the occasion. There's a reason why he's referred to as Captain Clutch. 

The sixty-four thousand dollar question for Rose is, can this Knicks team win with a seven foot center who is erratic offensively and takes stupid fouls? If the answer is yes, then I expect he will just add a depth piece at the deadline. If the answer is no, I wouldn't be surprised to see Towns traded.

But for whom? You can forget Giannis Antetokounmpo. The Greek Freak recently suffered his second calf injury this season - fourth in the last 19 months - and is out four to six weeks. Rose would be nuts to trade for a player who, despite his physical prowess, might not be available until mid March. And, besides, the Bucks have already turned down a proposed swap involving KAT. In other words, it ain't happening.

Another player that could be on the move is Guerschon Yabusele. After averaging 11 points per game for the Sixers last season, he has been a major disappointment for the Knicks this season. With a $5.5 million cap hit, I expect him to be included in a package for a guard or a forward regardless of whether they keep Towns or not.

One thing is certain: as presently constructed, this team will not beat Detroit in a best of seven series. The Pistons are bigger and deeper than the Knicks. To have any shot of advancing to the finals, the Knicks will have to get tougher and smarter. 

Nine days to go till the trade deadline. The pressure couldn't be higher on Rose.

Giants Get Their Man

This time, the Giants didn't fumble the ball on the one-yard line. This time, they took it into the end zone. It's been a rough stretch for Big Blue. Since they fired Tom Coughlin after the 2015 season, the Jints have gone through no less than five head coaches: Ben McAdoo, Steve Spagnuolo, Pat Shurmur, Joe Judge and Brian Daboll. Five coaches in ten years; all dismal failures. But this time, they didn't dick around. They set their sights on one man - the right man - and they landed him.

They sent Steve Tisch in his private jet to pick him up; they brought out the top guns - Eli, Coughlin, Jaxson Dart, the fucking ghost of Lombardi - to impress him; they wined and dined him; they did everything but kidnap him; and it worked.

Yes, Virginia, there is a Santa Claus.

To be honest, I was starting to have my doubts. When I went to bed around midnight, all indications were that John Harbaugh was on his way back to Baltimore and was scheduled to meet with the Tennessee Titans and Atlanta Flacons at his home over the weekend. Fuck, I thought. Another one bites the dust. 

Instead what happened was that both sides worked well into the evening on an agreement to bring the former Ravens head coach to MetLife. The exact terms have not yet been released, but the contract is believed to be for five years at just under $100 million, making Harbaugh one of the highest paid coaches in the NFL. It also gives him the power to hire his own assistants.

One of those assistants will undoubtedly be Todd Monken. The former offensive coordinator of the Ravens worked under Harbaugh the last three years. How good is Monken? In 2024, Baltimore became the first NFL team with 4,000 plus passing yards and 3,000 plus rushing yards in a single season, leading the league in total offense and yards per play.

So how did the Giants do it? How did they convince the most coveted coach since Andy Reid to sign with them on the first visit? As I wrote in an earlier piece, it came down to two things. The first was Dart. There is simply no substitute for having a franchise quarterback. Harbaugh was clearly impressed with the rookie and believes he can win with him. 

The second reason is more complicated. On paper, the Giants were a bad team, but on the field, between the Xs and Os, they were much better than their record indicated. Five times this season, they lost a game in which they held a double-digit lead; four of those losses came in the fourth quarter. Every one of those losses could just as easily have been a win. Harbaugh obviously felt the same way. 

Which brings us to the sixty-four thousand dollar question. How is Harbaugh going to improve a defense that folded like a cheap tent this season? By bringing in a competent defensive coordinator, that's how. One of the names being mentioned is Jim Schwartz. Over the last nine seasons, Schwartz has worked for the Bills, Eagles and Browns. Twice his defenses were top five in the NFL: 2017 with the Eagles and 2023 with the Browns. Assuming he doesn't take the Ravens job, he would be the best DC Big Blue has had since the days of Spags.

If he's not available, Antonio Pierce might be a good second choice. The former Giants linebacker and former Raiders interim head coach interviewed for the Giants head coaching vacancy last week. He was well respected by his players and went 5-4 during his brief stint in Vegas. Bringing him back would be more than a symbolic gesture to a suffering fanbase; it would signal to the league that the Giants are serious about assembling a coaching staff that can take this team to the next level. 

And what would the next level look like? Well, for starters, let's pump the brakes on making the playoffs. I expect the Giants will be considerably better under Harbaugh than Daboll, but making the playoffs in the NFC will be extremely tough, if not impossible. Excluding the four division winners, the Rams, 49ers and Packers will all be in the hunt in 2026, as will an improved Lions team. And don't forget about the Commanders. With a healthy Jayden Daniels, they should win 10 games easily. At best, I see this team winning 8 or 9 games.

For the time being, Giants fans will have to be satisfied with a team that is well coached and closes out games. Considering that Bill Parcells and Tom Coughlin went 3-12-1 and 6-10 respectively in their first seasons as head coach, and both went on to win two Super Bowls, that ain't bad.

Patience has become a four-letter word with this fanbase. This time around, it might actually pay off.

Where Will John Harbaugh Wind Up?

No sooner had I written my piece on who the next Giants head coach would be, that we learned the Miami Dolphins had fired their head coach Mike McDaniel. Naturally every Dolphins fan from Key West to Port St. Lucie assumed Harbaugh was going to be the Dolphins next head coach. After all, the owner Stephen Ross has more money than God, and Harbaugh is in tight with Ross; ergo it's a done deal. 

Jesus, how many Margaritas can those people drink down there? Even Jimmy Buffet's going, "Dude, chill out, they haven't even met with him yet."

For the record, every owner in the NFL is rich, and by rich, I mean filthy rich. The Giants are owned by John Mara, Steve Tisch and Julia Koch; the latter has a 10 percent stake and just happens to be worth $81 billion. Trust me, the Giants would have no problem forking over a sizable chunk of dough to get Harbaugh's signature on a contract.

So now that we've dispensed with the "Who's dick is bigger" portion of the piece, let's get down to what really matters; what will likely be the things that determine where Harbaugh coaches next season. Things like do they have a quarterback? How many holes do they have on the roster? What division do they play in? And how much control will he have? 

While there's no indication that Harbaugh is looking for total control of football operations - i.e., bring in his own GM - it is reasonable to assume he's looking for a collaborative relationship with the front office; one that gives him input into player personnel and the ability to hire his own assistants. 

There's another misperception that needs to be cleared up, and that's this idea that Harbaugh is the second coming of Vince Lombardi. He's not, and even if he were, none of these teams are the '66 Green Bay Packers. All of them have flaws; flaws that will need to be addressed for them to become title contenders. Indeed, the best team currently looking for a new head coach just happens to be the one that fired him, and even they went 8-9. 

Since I have a horse in this race, I thought I'd start with them first. 

New York Giants: The last 15 years notwithstanding, this is still considered a marque franchise with a rich history and four Super Bowls to its credit. Sherman, Parcells, Fassel, Coughlin. And those are just the head coaches. Lombardi, Landry, Belichick, and Payton have all cut their teeth as assistants with this organization. Harbaugh would be in good company.

The Giants lost five games this season in which they held a double-digit lead, four of those losses came in the fourth quarter. They have a young, talented quarterback in Jaxson Dart, a vastly improved offensive line, and some weapons on both sides of the ball. They are not as bad as their record would suggest. With the right coach, this could be an 8 or 9 win team next season.

Miami Dolphins: The last franchise to have a perfect season, the Fish present a tantalizing choice. If ever there was a fanbase that was starving to win a championship, it's this one. They have not been to the Super Bowl since 1985, and haven't won a playoff game since 2000. Harbaugh could be the next Don Shula.

Could be. That's because there are a couple of problems. Tua Tagovailoa and Tyreek Hill are due to make $108 million next season. That's a lot of salary to tie up just for two players. New GM Jon-Eric Sullivan will have to decide whether to keep both or trade them to free up cap space.

The other problem is location. Over the last forty years, there have been four warm-weather teams that have won the Super Bowl: the Tampa Bay Buccaneers (twice), the New Orleans Saints, and the Los Angeles Rams. Like it or not, warm-weather teams just don't do well in cold weather venues come January. Does Harbaugh really want to be the next Dave Wannstedt?

Atlanta Falcons: Frankly, I'm surprised more people aren't talking about them as a possibility. The Falcons play in arguably the worst division in the NFL. They had a strong finish to the season, winning their last four games to finish tied with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Carolina Panthers for first place. The Panthers won the division by virtue of a tie breaker. 

With Harbaugh, Atlanta could easily win 10 games every season, which would be more than enough to earn a home game in the playoffs. For a city that loves its football, he could run for mayor.

Cleveland Browns: Not to be confused with the original Browns franchise that moved to Baltimore, this Browns franchise has had very few things to celebrate since its inception in 1999. Ironically, they fired the only coach to win 11 games and coach of the year (twice) in Kevin Stefanski. 

Harbaugh's family is from the area. Hiring him as coach would be like the prodigal son returning home. The issue here is the GM, and a quarterback room that is more crowded than the L.I.E. during rush-hour. Like the NFC South, the AFC North is not a particularly strong division. 9 wins could be enough to win it.

Tennessee Titans: They have their quarterback in Cam Ward, but precious little else. This would be the ultimate re-build. If Harbaugh manages to pull it off, he would go down in history. 

Arizona Cardinals: An intriguing choice. They have the quarterback but unfortunately play in the same division as the Rams, 49ers and Seahawks. Not sure Harbaugh wants any part of that.

Las Vegas Raiders: Word has it Tom Brady has his sights set on Curt Cignetti of Indiana University, who just happens to coach Heinemann trophy winner and first overall pick Fernando Mendoza. Guess who holds the number one pick?

My thoughts? I think it comes down to the Giants, Dolphins, Falcons and Browns. That coincides with what Jay Glazer has reported. He spoke with Harbaugh who told him that he has narrowed the list of teams he will interview with down to three or four. Harbaugh is also said to be reviewing film on various players. I assume one of them is Dart. 

Like I wrote in my last piece, the Giants cannot afford to make the same mistake they made six years ago. If they truly believe that Harbaugh is the best man to coach this team, they need to make him an offer he can't refuse. Don't let him leave the building without signing him. If Mara has to give up his first-born grandchild, so be it.

I was in sales for 25 years, and I know for a fact that when a customer walks out of your store without a receipt in his hands, he rarely if ever comes back.

As Tommy Lugauer of WFAN pointed out: John Harbaugh has his pick of the litter here. It is up to Mara to make sure that pick is the Giants.

 

Previewing the Top Candidates for Next Giants Head Coach

Six years ago, the Giants found themselves in the exact same position they are in now. They had just fired Pat Shurmur and were looking for his replacement. They interviewed several candidates, including Mike McCarthy and Matt Rhule, but elected to go with Joe Judge.

We all know what happened, so there's no need rehashing it. Suffice to say that this time around, the Giants are hoping, praying, that they get the right man. Thankfully, there are three eminently qualified candidates available, along with a few potential dark horses. 

Given the stakes, I doubt that Joe Schoen and John Mara will seriously consider any of the dark horses, but with this franchise, you never know. Remember, it was Mara who was absolutely smitten with Judge during his interview and couldn't wait to hire him. 

For our purposes, I'll concentrate on the front runners. To be clear, any of these three men would make an excellent choice and be considerably better than either Brian Daboll or Mike Kafka. Having said that, though, I do have a pecking order. So without further ado,

John Harbaugh: Without question, the best coaching free agent to hit the open market since Andy Reid was fired by the Eagles, Harbaugh checks all the boxes and would instantly become the best head coach the Jints have had since Tom Coughlin. In 18 seasons with the Ravens, he was 193-124, including the playoffs. He won a Super Bowl in 2012 with Joe Flacco as his quarterback, but with Lamar Jackson, his teams have underachieved in the postseason.

Kevin Stefanski: In six seasons with the Browns, he made the playoffs twice, winning eleven regular-season games and coach of the year both times. That's quite an accomplishment for a franchise that since 1999 has had four winning seasons. Stefanski's claim to fame is working with quarterbacks, which will be crucial for the development of Jaxson Dart.

Mike McCarthy: In hindsight, Mara should've hired him back in 2020 instead of Judge. But that's water under the bridge. McCarthy is one of six head coaches in the history of the NFL to win twelve or more games with multiple franchises. He won a Super Bowl in 2010 with the Packers and had three consecutive 12-5 seasons with the Cowboys. But his lack of playoff success in Dallas led to a falling out with Jerry Jones. 

Now for the sixty-four thousand dollar question. Who would I go with? Obviously, Harbaugh would be my first choice. But if it turns out that he wants too much control - i.e., Bill Belichick in New England - I could see the Giants pivoting to Stefanski. And to be honest, I wouldn't be disappointed, provided they hire the right assistants. Imagine a staff of Stefanski as head coach, Kliff Kingsbury as offensive coordinator, and Antonio Pierce as defensive coordinator. That would arguably be the best coaching staff the Giants have had since their last Super Bowl team. As for McCarthy, he would be the safe pick. I don't love him, but I don't hate him either. Like I said, all three would be improvements over Daboll and Kafka.

One thing to keep in mind: the Giants aren't the only team looking to fill a coaching vacancy. Aside from Baltimore and Cleveland, the Atlanta Falcons, Las Vegas Raiders and Tennessee Titans also have their lines in the water. And the Falcons are especially intriguing because, unlike the other teams, they fired their coach and GM. That means they're in position to give whoever they hire total control over football operations. While's there's no indication that Harbaugh is looking for that much power, it's hard to imagine him turning down such an offer if it came his way.

We know that the Giants have already met with Stefanski and McCarthy; they've also met with Raheem Morris - the former Flacons head coach - and have a meeting scheduled with Pierce later this week, so they're in full compliance with the Rooney Rule. If Mara and Schoen like what they see when they sit down with Harbaugh next week, it would behoove them to make him an offer right there on the spot. Under no circumstances should they allow him to leave the building. On the other hand, if they're not enamored of Harbaugh, their very next call has to be to Stefanski. Get him in as soon as possible before another team snatches him up.

Six years ago, the Giants let two very qualified coaches slip through their fingers. They cannot afford to make that same mistake again. Time waits for no man, or organization. If Mara screws this up, he'll have no one but himself to blame.

The problem with casting a wide net is that sometimes the big fish gets away.